Showing posts with label Scotland. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Scotland. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 24, 2014

Deja Vu All Over Again

Such a Parcel of Rogues in a Nation is a Scottish folk song whose lyrics are taken from a Robert Burns poem of of the same name, dated 1791. It condemns those members of the Parliament of Scotland who signed the Act of Union with England in 1707, contrasting their treachery toward the nation with the tradition of martial valor and resistance commonly associated with national heroes such as Robert the Bruce and William Wallace. It has continued to be associated with Scottish nationalism.

Burns’s spirited denunciation of the rogues who sold Scotland for English gold refers to the Scottish commissioners who voted for the immoral Act of Union of 1707, some of whom were bribed.  It should be remembered that Burns was one of Scotland's most famous and celebrated Freemason.

The melody and lyrics were published in volume 1 ofJames Hogg's Jacobite Reliques of 1819 (no. 36).

Fareweel to a' our  Scottish fame
Fareweel our ancient glory
Fareweel e'en to our  Scottish name
Sae fam'd in martial story
Now Sark rins o'er the Solway sands
And Tweed rins tae the Ocean.
To mark where England's province stands
Sic a parcel of rogues in a nation.

What  force or guile could  not  subdue
Through many warlike ages
Is wrought now by a coward  few
For hireling traitors wages
The English steel we could disdain
Secure in valour's station.
But English gold has been our bane
Sic a parcel of rogues in a nation.

I would, ere I had seen the day
When treason thus could sell us
My auld grey head had lain in clay
Wi’ Bruce and loyal Wallace
But pith and power ‘till my last hour
I’ll mak' this declaration.
We were bought and sold for English gold
Sic a parcel of rogues in a nation.

Saturday, June 21, 2014

Freemasons: Amnesiac Saint John's Men

Once upon a time, in an ancient kingdom, Freemasons knew who and what they were. That was before the grey, amnesia inducing fog of fish fries and Grand Lodge hegemony made Freemasons forget why they really existed. We probably shouldn't speak in Masonic contexts of the Lost Word, but the Lost Purpose.

What they were, and what we should still be, according to all those knowledgable sources, are Saint John's men. As Tobias Churton, in his book "The Mysteries of John the Baptist: His Legacy in Gnosticism, Paganism, and Freemasonry" notes,
"There are in the world two principle groups of people for whom John the Baptist has significant spiritual meaning, though in the case of Freemasons, I should say a group for whom John ought to have spiritual meaning; Masons have mostly forgotten why they were once "St. John's men." The problem is, that while all of those sources go on to tell us about Saint John in relation to various Orders, and obscure and venerable middle eastern religions, they never get around to offering more than incidents and accidents when it comes to Freemasonry and the Saints John.


In looking for something to post in honor of Saint John's Day, I found that there really is very little available that isn't repetitive or simplistic, that isn't directly related to Freemasonry. So, I found myself turning to Ars Quatuor Corantorum. I found that for the most part, that august journal shed more heat than light on this topic.


In France, and by extension, Haiti, Saint John's Day is celebrated with bonfires. That however, reflects little more than that they continue what is a general practice in Celtic and some formerly Celtic countries.


Whether such practices played a ritualistic role in operative Freemasonry in Scotland is thus far unknown to me. Perhaps it is a topic some masons in Scotland might be motivated to take up. It is one of the many fascinating questions I continue to be plagued with.


And so I continue my search. I just don't find the legends of Templars and Hospitallers informed enough to provide much satisfaction. In any case, I'm more interested in what that association translated into in terms of ritual and content. Until then, hints and allegations will have to suffice, and I will have to continue to look for the angels in the architecture.

Friday, June 6, 2014

Landscapes and Legends: Iona and Heredom

Eilean Idhe (Iona)
The question of how Freemasonry as we know it today came into being stumps Masons as much as it does non-Masons. Until recently, we had mostly volumes  which contained almost as much speculation and wishful thinking as fact. That 19th century scholarship had its limitations is nobody's fault. With the exception of the more dogmatic author's they did the best they could with what they had. If we do not welcome what contemporary academics have to offer however, that will be nobody's fault but our own. 

A well honed aversion to fact is actually a problem freemasons share with a large part of our population today; a preference for myth and legend over documented fact.  It's difficult to deal with modern research that overturns treasured myths about the foundation of an institution with which one has a deep, heartfelt connection. However, when that institution is dedicated to seeking light, by which we mean, or should mean, both knowledge and understanding, then we have an obligation to look our fond delusions in the eye and banish them. 

Sìdh Chailleann (Schiehallion)
Sometimes, however, we have nothing really solid with which to replace our myths. At that point, we need to embrace the poetic and visionary of our traditions while acknowledging the limits of our sight. Facts sometimes get blurred in the mists of ages past.

Scotland is the original home of what we understand to be modern Freemasonry. We are blessed with a number of documents concerning real Freemasonry in Scotland before 1717. However, modern Freemasonry contains in it's foundational myths, material which we are unable to verify. It also contains legends, which are grounded in the understandings of the time at which our existing institutions were created. These understandings are further complicated by the literature written about them since. I am not referring to 21st century scholarship, but that of the 18th and 19th centuries in particular. One such institution is the Royal Order of Scotland.


This post does not intend to question either the value or intentions of that august order which has existed since at least 1741. Rather, it seeks to raise some points, and mostly, speak about some myths concerning the origins of Freemasonry in Scotland. Unfortunately, I do not have many answers to the questions concerning the original sources of Freemasonry in Scotland. There are a few clarifications that can be made, and they also leave open many more questions. 

I hold little hope that some of these myths may be confirmed as fact. My motive stems from an abiding interest in Freemasonry, and also the history of Scotland and the Gaelic world. If it is possible to raise a few points and in the process, inspire some curiosity to look anew at these issues, and get those interested in them to introduce some newer scholarship into Masonic discussions, then that would be wonderful. There may be some out there able to bring new insight to the subject.

A real problem in looking at Masonic writing on this subject is that it is inevitably in English. 19th century Masonic literature suffers from a dearth of accurate knowledge about Gaelic culture. Inevitably, when it lacked sound information, the impulse then was to fill in the gaps with uniformed speculation.

Scota, the Egyptian-Irish Queen
Mackey’s Encyclopedia of Freemasonry, in seeking to flesh out the origins of Freemasonry in Scotland turned his sights on a group called the Culdees (>Gaelic, Céili Dé) Earlier Medieval legends, which may have some some basis in fact, associated the Early Irish with Egypt, though perhaps not as they suggest. The Céili Dé may have had monastic connections with early Egyptian Christianity. A legend speaks of an Egyptian Queen, Scota, who travelled to Ireland. The Medieval Story He asserted, with no real documentation to confirm such a claim that "in A.D. 546 St. Columba, an ordained Culdee Priest founded with a college or fraternity of Operative Masons, an abbey at Derry Ireland. Seventeen years later in 563 he with 12 Brethren called the Apostles of Ireland, founded a monastery at the Isle of Iona in Scotland." He then went on to state that the Royal Order of Scotland (ROS) maintained was its descendant and Freemasonry as we know it today from the Grand Lodge of England descended from the Royal Order of Scotland.  In one grand leap of imagination he claimed a direct link between the early Irish Christian church and modern Freemasonry.  He then informed us that the two patron saints of the Culdees were Saint John the Baptist and Saint John the Divine. 

Myth makers go on to link Heredom with both the mountain of Schiehallion  (Sìdh Chailleann) which lies at the approximate geographic center of Scotland, as well as Iona, with the birth of Scottish Freemasonry. While it makes wonderful legend, mysterious and romantic, there is alas, no documentation to confirm it. The lack of documentation, combined with a healthy dose of Templar legend is alluring. 

As much as I would love to place the origins of modern Freemasonry on Iona, or at Schiehallion, Gaelic language traditions are remarkably silent. While Gaelic remained the predominant language among the community on Iona, throughout the 19th and into the early 20th centuries, they retained relatively few traditions concerning Saint Columbkille, the original founder of Iona's monastery, and virtually none concerning Freemasonry. 


None of these inconvenient truths refute the Scottish origins of modern Freemasonry. Nor do they prove that there is no connection between Iona (or Schiehallion) and Freemasonry. They simply mean we do not have the evidence. The obvious connection was the documentable association of Iona with the royal institutions of Scotland. The fact that Iona is identified as a holy place long before Christianity adds both romance and credibility to its possible influence. Before it was known as the center for St. Combkille, it was known, among other names such as Ì nam ban bòidheach (the isle of beautiful women) and Inis nan Druidhneach (The Druid's Island). The Norse name for Iona,  Hiōe means Island of the den of the fox. Strabo called it Eo, which suggests an association with the Yew tree, sacred to the Druids.


Monastary At Iona
The monastery of Iona, founded c. 563 played a significant role in the Christianization of the Picts in the late 6th century and of the Anglo-Saxon kingdom of Northumbria in 635. It became a major center of learning, and its scriptorium produced highly influential documents, including quite likely, the original texts of the Iona Chronicle, the source for the early Irish annals. The monastery is often associated with the distinctive practices and traditions known as Celtic Christianity.

The ancient burial ground, called  Rèilig Odhrain (Oran's cemetery), contains the 12th century chapel of Naomh Odhrán ( St. Oran, Columba's uncle), contains a number of medieval graves. The abbey graveyard contains the graves of many early Scottish Kings, as well as kings from Ireland, Norway and France. Iona became the burial site for the kings of Dál Riata and their successors.  In 1549 an inventory of 48 Scottish, 8 Norwegian and 4 Irish kings was recorded. The documented burials there include:


Cináed mac Ailpín, king of the Picts (also known today as "Kenneth I of Scotland")
Domnall mac Causantín, alternatively "king of the Picts" or "king of Alba" (Donald II)
Máel Coluim mac Domnaill, king of Scotland (Malcolm I)
Donnchad mac Crínáin, king of Scotland (Duncan I)
Mac Bethad mac Findlaích, king of Scotland (MacBeth)
Domnall mac Donnchada, king of Scotland (Domnall Bán or Donald III)

So, while it is necessary to recognize that the Masonic literature concerning these matters is unquestionably legend rather than fact, that does not mean that the truth is not enshrined in these stories. The proofs are lost in the mists of time. Denying they hold the truth is as much a folly as holding these myths without question. If someone would only seek more light. As the old folks in my youth said when they saw someone working, Báil ó Dhía air an obair (God bless the work)...

Saturday, January 26, 2013

International Conference on the History of Freemasonry 2013


INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON THE HISTORY OF FREEMASONRY
FREEMASONS' HALL, 96 GEORGE STREET, EDINBURGH, SCOTLAND
24 MAY- 26 MAY 2013


The first International Conference on the History of Freemasonry was held in 2007 to establish whether or not Freemasonry could be considered a single separate subject worthy of its own platform. It is now clear based on the successes of ICHF 2007, 2009 and 2011 that answer is a resounding, YES. Whilst the organisers welcome invitations from Masonic bodies throughout the world to host ICHF within their own locale, there is something comforting in bringing ICHF 2013 back to where it began; Freemasons' Hall, Edinburgh, Scotland. 2013 is significant in several respects, not least because it marks the 200th anniversary of the 1813 union of the two English Grand Lodges, the Ancient and Moderns, under the auspices of the Duke of Sussex (1773 - 1843). Undoubtedly a number of researchers will submit proposals for papers on this very subject.

Lodge Aitcheson's Haven
1813 also saw the admission of Lodge Aitcheson's Haven to The Grand Lodge of Scotland - the significance being that this Lodge's records are the oldest extant, commencing on 9th January 1599. As many are aware Edinburgh is known as the 'Athens of the North' due to its much admired architecture. Worthy also of note is that several famous architects who lived and worked in Edinburgh were indeed Freemasons, some examples being Robert and James Adam (1728 - 92 and 1732 - 94 respectively), Charles R. Cockerell (1788 - 1863), David Bryce (1803 - 76) and Sir Robert Lorimer (1864 - 1929). As stated definitively in the Statement of Purpose it is the intent of the Promoters, Supersonic Events Ltd., to ensure that any profits generated from these conferences are directed to and for the promotion of Freemasonry.

Young Researchers Fund
It is anticipated that the Promoters will shortly be in a position to create a Young Researchers Fund - details to follow in the Second Announcement.

Despite considerable rising costs to hold these events, the Organisers are pleased to announce that the cost of attending ICHF 2013 will be £250. The future of ICHF is bright as recent discussions have secured a Canadian venue for ICHF 2015. Further details of this and ICHF 2017 will be released in due course.

Held under the Patronage of:

Charles Iain R. Wolrige Gordon of Esslemont
The Grand Master Mason

J.M. Marcus Humphrey of Dinnet, C.B.E. O.St.J
The Sovereign Grand Commander of
The Supreme Council for Scotland of the Ancient and Accepted Scottish Rite

Sir Archibald D. Orr Ewing, Bt. MA
The Deputy Grand Master and Governor of the Royal Order of Scotland

with the special Patronage of:
11th Earl of Elgin and 15th Earl of Kincardine, KT



and with the support of:    
       
The Academic Society for Research into Freemasonry and Fraternalism
Centre interdisciplinaire bordelais d'étude des lumières-Lumières Nature Société
Université de Bordeaux III Centre d'étude de la Littérature Françaises des XVIIe
et XVIIIe Siècles (CELLF)
Sorbonne IV. Paris Chair of Freemassonary, Faculty of Religious Studies
University of Leiden Centre de la Méditerrannée Moderne et Contemporaine
Université de Nice Sophia-Antipolis, The Interdisciplinary Research Group Freemasonry
The Free University of Brussels


The conference is supported
by numerous academic institutions.
Conference promoted by:
Supersonic Events Ltd.


Thursday, June 28, 2012

Conference on Second Sight and Prophecy in Aberdeen


Call for Papers - with apologies for cross posting

'Second Sight and Prophecy'
University of Aberdeen on 14-16 June 2013

Conference organised by the School of Divinity, History and Philosophy, and the Elphinstone Institute at the University of Aberdeen; sponsored by the Folklore Society

This interdisciplinary conference welcomes participants from a range of academic disciplines including History, Folklore, Anthropology, Divinity and Sociology whose research interests cover a wide range of topics exploring varying methods used by different cultures (both now and in the past) to look into the future and the rationale for so doing. The future has always held a fascination for humankind especially in times of tribulation and this is worthy of academic discussion in light of the changes affecting so many of us in our current global context. The role in culture of seers and prophets, by whatever name they are known, and the use of rituals, drugs and sacred sites, etc. will be examined.

Abstracts of 300 words are invited on any of the following or related topics. These should be submitted by 15 November 2012 to the conference convenor, Dr Alex Sutherland, History Department, University of Aberdeen; a.m.sutherland@abdn.ac.uk               

Papers might address:
Astrology and its rationale(s) for predicting the future.
Biblical prophecy as depicted in the arts.
Divination in any form.
English attitudes to second sight.
Healing wells.
How modern scientists have appropriated the persona of the prophet or visionary seer.
Landscape and prophecy in art.
Old Norse and later Scandinavian sources on prophecy.
Popular Catholic belief in prophecy before and after the Reformation.
Prophecy in Native American tribes.
Prophetic utterances by the courts, commoners, and the church.
Reading the future in the landscape of settlements.
Renaissance science and astrology.
Sami shamanism.
Second sight and prophecy in Scottish Gaeldom.
Second sight and prophecy in the Viking world.
Second sight in Gaelic traditions as they survived and evolved in Nova Scotian communities.
Seers and seeresses in medieval Icelandic saga literature.
The early Islamic world & its connections with astrology.
The role of prophecies, visions and dreams in poetry and allegorical tales.
The role of prophecy in the origins of Islam, in the pre-Islamic Arabian environment
The use of sites, dreams and ancestors for prophecies by indigenous peoples.
Visual and verbal imagery of natural objects as coded language for the use of entheogens to attain divine / prophetic knowledge.
Welsh prophetic poetry.
When prophecy fails.

Dr Alex Sutherland
School of Divinity, History and Philosophy
History Department
Crombie Annexe
Meston Walk
Aberdeen AB24 3FX
Tel: 01224 273051




The University of Aberdeen is a charity registered in Scotland, No SC013683.

Thursday, June 21, 2012

Freemasonry and Higher Education


Liberal Arts Lodge, LA California
The contemporary  interaction between Freemasonry and Higher Education is bearing fruit.

Unlike today, it was once evident to others in society that Freemasonry had something to contribute to Civil Society. Mainstream Freemasonry may still hold onto that assumption, but whether it be correct or not, convincing modern society to share that belief becomes every day more difficult.  Is there any truth to our assumption?

As the writer of this blog, it is safe to make some assumptions concerning my view. Looking back in time, one clear piece of evidence that Freemasonry was considered valuable are the number of legacy lodges with names such as University Lodge.

University of Pennsylvania Regalia
Until at least the last half of the 20th Century, many universities, including the Ivy Leagues, had active lodges, not merely in their neighborhoods or near their campuses, but quite often on them, and made up almost entirely of current students and alumni. A very few of these have survived, such as Liberal Arts Lodge in Los Angeles ( http://liberalarts677.com/ ). Others remain as vestiges of their former selves, having been folded into other lodges through merger or even multiple mergers as the presence of Freemasonry has diminished over the years. An example of such a lodge was University Lodge formerly associated with my alma mater, the University of Pennsylvania. By the time I attended Penn, I doubt anyone on campus had heard of University Lodge, and it was no longer meeting on campus.  I note that Rutgers University in New Jersey has a Masonic Alumni Association, which is apparently still active and even has an online presence (http://rumasonic.blogspot.com/2009/01/academia-freemasonry.html).

In Europe, at least in England and Scotland, Masonic Lodges may be found on a number of University Campuses, and generally Masonic efforts at outreach to university students there is less half-hearted than it is in the US.

However, there is another way in which Freemasonry is associated with Higher Education and in this case, it is beginning to advance rather than retreat.  I am referring to Freemasonry as the subject of academic study.

When academics look at Freemasonry as an institution, and at its history, what passes for historic fact among some segments of both regular and liberal  may not stand up to their objective scrutiny.  "Regular" Masonic definitions of what constitutes Freemasonry will only be viewed as applying to "Regular" Masonry, and that will not be privileged over other forms of Freemasonry and vise versa. That is the objectivity of academia.  Such views will inevitably impact the discussion and the literature on Freemasonry, and ultimately, however uncomfortable such "revelations" may be to some, they will aid in creating a more accurate and complete understanding of the institution.

What will be gained by the growth of academic scrutiny will be a more accurate understanding of the factual history of the Craft, and greater serious attention to its role, both historic and contemporary, in the development of civil society and social institutions.  It is important to emphasize that this academic interest and scrutiny is already happening.

There are a number of Academic programs already in place or in development that deal either solely with Freemasonry or place it in the context of larger social or philosophical systems. Some of these will be noted here.

UCLA
One of the earliest was The Center for Research into Freemasonry at the University of Sheffield, which launched back in 2000.  While this program was lamentably suspended in 2010, the work begun in this program continues elsewhere.

One such place is at UCLA in the United States. UCLA under the excellent guidance of Dr. Margarite Jacobs, is providing a home for the study of Freemasonry in Civil Socirty and the opportunity for doctoral candidates to produce and offer courses related to this research (http://www.freemasonryandcivilsociety.ucla.edu/ ).  Further, the Roosevelt Center, also in Los Angeles, and in close communication with UCLA, is developing avenues for further research and is soon to include publishing among its concerns (http://www.scoop.it/t/john-slifko-roosevelt-center , http://www.therooseveltcenter.org/)

Under the umbrella of another advancing field in academic study, the School of Humanities at the University of Exeter, in England, offers a  MPhil/PhD Western Esotericism and  MA in Western Esotericism, under the auspices of their Exeter Center for the Study of Esotericism (EXESECO) (http://centres.exeter.ac.uk/exeseso/)  For those unfamiliar with the structure of such disciplines, the following text taken from the Exeter Center's site should make it clear that such programs are not devoted to the practice of esotericism, although students may or may not persue such concerns personally, but rather are committed to examining the development and distribution of such systems in human society and their impact upon everything from religion, popular culture and politics.

Exeter
The purpose of the Exeter Centre for the Study of Esotericism (EXESESO) is to foster advanced research into historical and comparative aspects of the esoteric traditions from the Hellenistic period in late antiquity through the Renaissance and early modern period to the present. Staff members in the departments of History (with interests in religion, culture, science and medicine), Sociology and Philosophy, Theology, Classics and Ancient History, and the Institute of Arab and Islamic Studies, collaborate in seminars, research and publications. Literary and philosophical traditions are also examined by colleagues in the Schools of English and Modern Languages (departments of French, German, Italian, Hispanic Studies, and Russian).
Postgraduate and postdoctoral members of EXESESO will be able to pursue research projects with the support of the Centre's panel of distinguished scholars across a number of departments and disciplines.
There are three main objectives:
to document and analyse new subjects (figures, groups and movements) in the history of esotericism, thereby making an original contribution to scholarly knowledge.
to gain insight into the social, religious and philosophical changes, which are conducive to esotericism and to assess its influence on culture, politics and society.
to develop an understanding of the fundamental characteristics which define esoteric spirituality, which often manifests as a form of religious experience, while offering a perspective upon the individual soul in the context of nature and the universe.  (http://centres.exeter.ac.uk/exeseso/)

Not to be outdone, such endeavors are not occurring only in Anglophone institutions of Higher Learning. The Spanish University UNED, through its Department of History of Law and Institutions, provides the following information about its programs:

Master in History of Freemasonry in Spain (60 credits)
Specialist College in History of Fraternal Philanthropic Orders, Corporations, Schools and Societies (40 credits)
University Expert in the History of Freemasonry in Spain and Latin America (25 credits)

This program provides a grant of 20% over the official price of tuition to all students enrolled during the academic year 2012-2013.

This modular program provides a rigorous and methodical knowledge of the history of Masonic associations in its various forms, orders, corporations, academies and scientific societies, cultural, philanthropic, fraternal, charitable, philosophical and developments. Particular reference is made to fraternal and philanthropic movements and utopian thought and modern and contemporary perennialism,  studying its culture, both spiritual and ideological.
(http://www.fundacion.uned.es/)

Gracias a Victor Guerra / Thanks to John Slifko.